This website or its third-party tools use cookies which are necessary to its functioning and required to improve your experience. By clicking the consent button, you agree to allow the site to use, collect and/or store cookies.
The platform this site runs on doesn't have the option to turn off cookies server side, but you can do that in your browser and then return to the site.
I accept
Deny cookies Go Back

Annielytics.com

I make data sexy

  • About
  • Resources
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Log In

Dec 18 2017

Google Analytics Campaign Tagging Disasters In The Wild: An Exposé

Google Analytics campaign tagging disasters

What’s not to love about learning from others’ mistakes in life? That’s what I aim to help you do in this post.

I know I hit on campaign tagging and channels A LOT. Here are my resources to date:

  • Campaign tagging guide
  • Channels guide
  • Post with guidance on how to tag social ads
  • Post on customizing channel groups

So you may be asking yourself, “Why can’t she let this go?”

Why? I’ll tell you why. Because campaign tagging is the number one cause I see for serious issues in Google Analytics audits.

You might ask yourself, in followup, “Then why would she keep writing about this since campaign tagging disasters are her job security?”

Yeah, I don’t really have an answer for that one.

Anywho, let’s kick off with mistakes I’ve seen from publishers.

Publisher Errors

I keep a note in my Evernote of campaign tagging issues I see as I’m out and about roaming the web. I’ve been holding onto it for a few years, so some of the examples were dated. But I pulled up each of the site’s Facebook pages, and if they corrected the errors of their ways, I didn’t use them as a cautionary tale.

With each link, I’ll share what’s wrong with it and how I would recommend fixing it. Of course, these sites might have already implemented the fixes I recommend, but that would be rare. And publishers are the worst offenders I’ve found to date of campaign tagging disasters. However, I’ll share some examples of campaign tagging disasters I’ve found on other sites.

Gawker

Gawker is now defunct, but before it went under, their social team made plenty of gaffes of their own.

Example Link

http://gawker.com/how-things-work-1785604699?utm_campaign=socialflow_gawker_facebook&utm_source=gawker_facebook&utm_medium=socialflow

What’s Wrong

  • Google doesn’t recognize ‘socialflow’ as a medium, so all of this tagged traffic would show up in Google’s (Other) channel. I see this issue quite frequently with tools that use Social Flow. Check out my latest post on channels to find out which mediums you can use. (I share a resource from Google’s site that’s pure gold.)
  • Source should be ‘facebook.com’.
  • Campaign feels like a lost opportunity in that ‘facebook’ is already included in the source. It’s up to a social team to decide how granular they want to get with their campaign names, but none of these elements scream campaign to me.

How To Fix

  • Change medium to ‘social’ or a medium Google recognizes. (‘social’ is the easiest.)
  • Change source to ‘facebook.com’.
  • Customize Social channel to include ‘socialflow’. I demonstrate how to accomplish this fix in the gif below.
customize social channel in Google Analytics
Click for larger image

The Independent

Example Link

http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/hugh-jackman-wont-join-mcu-wolverine-x-men-disney-fox-deal-a8111726.html?utm_campaign=Echobox&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Facebook

What’s Wrong

  • Google Analytics engineers made the tragic decision to make campaign parameters case sensitive and didn’t account for the very real possibility that marketers would capitalize their mediums. Ergo, Google has no idea what ‘Social’ is and files it in its junk drawer — the (Other) channel. ?
  • I would tag the source as ‘facebook.com’, not ‘Facebook’. The reason is you should ideally mimic how sources naturally appear in Google Analytics. For referrals it’s just the domain, with the exception of Google Plus. Then it shows up as plus.google.com or plus.url.google.com.

How To Fix

  • If you’re using a campaign tagging resource like the Google Doc I’ve made publicly available, force mediums to lowercase.
  • Add a line item in your channel definitions that use ‘matches regex’ to make them not case insensitive, as I’ve demonstrated in the screenshot below.
customizing the social channel in Google Analytics
Click for larger image

BuzzFeed

Example Link

https://www.buzzfeed.com/claudiarosenbaum/dustin-hoffman-new-sexual-misconduct-allegations?utm_term=.hhbxeDQLK0&utm_source=bffbbuzzfeed&ref=bffbbuzzfeed#.viqYELNOKD

What’s Wrong

  • It’s missing the most important parameter: medium! This traffic will show up in BuzzFeed’s (Other) channel because there’s no medium telling Google to send it to their Social channel.
  • utm_source should be set to a real source: facebook.com.
  • Any extra details (like what they have in source) should be put into the content parameter.
  • There should be a campaign name.

How To Fix

  • Set medium to ‘social’.
  • Set source to ‘facebook.com’.
  • Customize Social channel to include sources that match ‘bffbbuzzfeed’ to future proof the channel.
  • Create a custom channel grouping that they can use to see how their historical data would be impacted. I’ve demonstrated how in the gif below, which is easier than the process I shared in my channels guide. H/t to Mark Traphagen for the streamlined process!
how to create a custom channel grouping in Google Analytics
Click for larger image

Pro Tip: One serious benefits to custom channel groupings is they are available in the Channels report as well as your Multi-Channel Funnels reports. Your customized Default Channel Grouping isn’t available to your in your MCF reports. The sad thing about the custom channel groupings is that they have to be shared (even among users in the same organization), and they’re not available to you through the API. ?

Bustle

Example Link

https://www.bustle.com/p/perms-are-making-a-comeback-you-may-actually-want-one-7607452?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=owned&utm_campaign=bustle

What’s Wrong

  • Google doesn’t recognize ‘owned’ as a social medium.
  • ‘facebook’ isn’t how this referral shows up in GA reports.
  • ‘bustle’ isn’t a very useful campaign name.

How To Fix

  • Set medium to ‘social’.
  • Add ‘.com’ to source.
  • Consider using a campaign name a little more insightful than the name of your organization.

Errors on Other Sites

Publishers aren’t the only ones messing up their campaign tagging. Let’s pick on learn from some other sites’ mistakes.

nj.com

Example Link

http://www.nj.com/hunterdon/index.ssf/2017/07/no_bull_landmark_nj_country_western_club_suddenly.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

What’s Wrong

  • ‘twitter’ isn’t a medium; it’s a source.
  • ‘dlvr.it’ isn’t a source; it’s a social media automation tool.
  • There’s no campaign.

How To Fix

  • Set medium to ‘social’.
  • Set source to ‘twitter.com’.
  • Add dlvr.it to content if you want to include that detail.
  • Include an intuitive campaign name.

iskn

Example Link

https://store.iskn.co/products/slate?utm_source=Facebook&utm_medium=Video&utm_content=Web_Serie_e01_&utm_campaign=Consideration

What’s Wrong

  • This link was shared on Facebook so the medium should set to ‘social’, not ‘Video’.
  • ‘Facebook’ isn’t how this source shows up in Google Analytics.
  • Campaign name seems pretty vague.

How To Fix

  • Set medium to ‘social’.
  • Set source to ‘facebook.com’.
  • Consider creating a more intuitive campaign name.

Product Hunt

Example Link

https://www.producthunt.com/posts/api-list?utm_source=browser_notification&utm_medium=browser_notification&utm_campaign=api-list

What’s Wrong

  • You don’t want to use the same value for multiple parameters.
  • Google doesn’t recognize ‘browser_notification’ as a medium.
  • Source should be the site this links lives on. Since this link was sent to me over Slack, I don’t know where it originated. If it’s a browser notification that can pop up on any site, they’ll need to be creative as to the source, much like we have to do with email (which I explain in my campaign tagging guide)

How To Fix

  • I actually like browser notification as a medium. I would use a plus sign instead of an underscore so that it shows up as a space in your GA reports. (Again, I demonstrate this technique in my campaign tagging guide and my most recent post on channels. But that’s just a styling preference on my part.
  • Create a Browser Notification custom channel to rescue this traffic from your (Other) channel. In the gif below I set it to recognize a space or underscore. If you want to learn how to use regex in Google Analytics like a baws, check out my super nerdy regex post. (I break it down in the simplest terms.)
create new channel in Google Analytics
Click for larger image

Hipmunk

Example Link

https://www.hipmunk.com/hotels?variant=cnntravel&utm_source=cnntravel&utm_campaign=cnn&utm_medium=search_partnership&utm_content=30perc4starnycsave1#w=New+York+City,+NY;i=2016-01-08;o=2016-01-10

What’s Wrong

  • Google doesn’t recognize the medium ‘search_partnership’.
  • ‘cnntravel’ isn’t a valid source. Source should be the domain the link lives on. Additional details can be dropped into the content parameter.
  • ‘cnn’ isn’t a good campaign name.

How To Fix

  • Create a custom Partner channel for links of this nature. Include any other mediums you want to use to populate this channel, separating them with a pipe character (above the backslash character on the keyboard).
  • Use ‘cnn.com’ as the source. Drop travel into the content parameter.
  • Give the campaign a more intuitive name, like ‘travel link’ or whatever makes sense to the team.

Find Your Disasters

There’s an often overlooked channel in Google Analytics’ Channels report (Acquisition > All Traffic > Channels) called (Other). This is where good data goes to die. It’s a barren land filled with social, retargeting, email, and other precious marketing data. It’s time to turn that around. (Annie, what are you blathering on about?)

You’ll want to click on that line item and then change the primary dimension in the subsequent report to Medium by clicking on Other and typing “med” in the filter to pull it up. If you’re a visual learner, follow the animated gif below.

Mistagged mediums in Google Analytics
How to go spelunking for mangled up campaign data ?

Need More Help?

If you’re still unsure about how to fix your campaign tagging issues and create custom channels that work for your business, I offer several options to help get you out of a rut:

  • Hangouts: Grab an hour or two to pepper me with your campaign tagging issues. I use a conferencing service that also allows us to share screens easily. So I can make changes while you watch or vice versa. Then I send you a copy of the video of our session.
  • Analytics Audit: These are comprehensive deep dives into your analytics issues that include an investigation of your campaigns and channels.
  • Analytics Tuneups: These are pared down analytics audits that include the most common issues I see in audits. Not a guarantee these will be your account’s biggest issues, but it’s a good option for startups and smaller sites.
  • Analytics Audit Template: On a really tight budget or want to learn to do your own DIY analytics audit? It doesn’t get less expensive than this. For $295 you get a 200+-page illustrated template that walks you through how to perform your own analytics audit. You can also use it to train new analysts on how to customize (or fix) your Google Analytics implementations.

 

Written by Annie Cushing · Categorized: Analytics · Tagged: Campaign Tagging, Channel, Custom Channels, Google Analytics

Comments

  1. Matt Kirk says

    December 18, 2017 at 11:00 AM

    Hey Annie,

    I’m wondering: do you think it would be valuable to also put nginx / apache rewrite rules on a server to fix these campaign tracking mishaps. It seems like a lot of these are pretty simple fixes that could be automated as an nginx module. For years I’ve been harping on people about tagging correctly (I’m a developer not a marketer) but it still happens.

    I’ve also seen some pretty awful tagging campaigns like the one time I saw 1k of text in utm_* parameters :-D.

    Best,

    Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      December 18, 2017 at 10:11 PM

      It’s a really creative idea, but … I wouldn’t recommend it. Only because there wouldn’t be any transparency around it. I mean you’ll know you set it up, but months or years down the road someone else might come along and be completely flummoxed by the disparity between your tags and your data. At minimum, I’d add an annotation to your account (in each of the views that would be impacted by this change) alerting marketers downstream of the change. But most marketers don’t look in the annotations to see changes. So it’s still a risky move, even if it would work well. My $0.02.

      Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      December 18, 2017 at 10:12 PM

      That said, my inner scientist is DYING to know if it works. DY. ING. So if you DO set this up, even as a test, I’d love to know the result!

      Reply
  2. Brett says

    December 20, 2017 at 12:11 PM

    Hi Annie!

    I think I can give some insight on why tracking codes might be setup like your examples (to some extent anyway).

    I usually see tracking like these examples because the data is being pulled from GA to a database to be sorted and organized later. For instance, I can see Bustle using the medium as owned so they can sort all of their owned vs paid social traffic separately in a third party reporting tool or an analysis tool.

    When this happens, I usually create a custom channel grouping (I don’t like to edit the default grouping because other users may not realize it has been edited) that reorganized this data to how it is reported in any third party tool. But, the best solution IMO is to create a custom parameter with a unique ID that can be connected to an unlimited number of variables in a third party database.

    Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      December 20, 2017 at 12:31 PM

      Hi Brett,

      Thanks for stopping by! I agree that there could be any number of reasons sites use custom mediums. But my experience is that they usually DON’T create custom channels for it. Publishers typically have robust (Other) channels with a lot of their tagged traffic and don’t know to check it to rescue that data. Using ‘owned’ is a particularly bad option, imo, b/c it’s very broad. Owned is anything that’s not paid, so organic search traffic falls into that category. In any case, they just need to make adjustments to ensure it’s in the proper channels in their reports.

      One huge disadvantage to relying on custom channel groupings is that they’re not available in the API. That’s fine for mom and pop shops who typically aren’t using dashboards to track their traffic. But most publishers are. So I use them for forensic purposes, but for anything that needs to show up in their dashboards, modifying the DCG is a must.

      Reply
  3. Jeremy says

    January 16, 2018 at 3:06 PM

    Doesn’t traffic from Facebook without UTM tags get sorted into “facebook.com / referral”? Your advocate using “social” for the medium, is that to sort out tagged Facebook traffic from non-tagged?

    Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      January 16, 2018 at 3:21 PM

      Yes, exactly. This way you can segment organic social from social traffic that’s a result of your social shares.

      Reply
  4. Scott Thomas says

    March 29, 2018 at 5:33 PM

    Do you have any advice for tagging Google my Business links with UTM tagging? I’ve seen some folks claim a lot of GMB listing traffic gets dumped into direct / none.

    Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      March 29, 2018 at 5:50 PM

      I know bigger companies like PetSmart have been doing it for years (link to screenshot: https://www.screencast.com/t/PQ3n4HJr0oo). Personally, I would create a custom channel for it (google / local for source / medium). But I understand why they used google / organic for source / medium. But I’m a huge fan of custom channels.

      Reply
  5. John Hughes says

    June 18, 2018 at 9:59 AM

    Annie, what are your thoughts on using a GA filter to force the utm_medium to lowercase?

    Reply
    • Annie Cushing says

      June 18, 2018 at 10:24 AM

      Google uses the raw, prefiltered campaign data, so a lowercase filter has no effect. I was very surprised to find this out a few years ago doing an analytics audit.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CAN I HELP YOU FIND SOMETHING?

‘MAKING DATA SEXY’ IS LIVE ?

Want to learn how to create compelling, aesthetically pleasing charts in Excel? Learn how with Making Data Sexy.

Note: Also offered for Mac

STUFF I BLOG ABOUT

LEARN HOW TO USE ALL THE TOOLS

marketing strategy guide

DIY marketing strategy guide. This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to perform 66 unique marketing tasks using 15 reputable marketing tools (both free and paid). Steal it for $295! Learn more.

LEARN TO DO A SITE AUDIT

site audit template

DIY site audit template. 20 sections, 215 checkpoints, 100+ explainer graphics, 218 pages, step-by-step instructions. Steal it for $295! Learn more.

LEARN TO DO AN ANALYTICS AUDIT

analytics audit template

DIY analytics audit template. 8 sections, 61 checkpoints, 100+ explainer graphics, 205 pages, step-by-step instructions. Steal it for $295! Learn more.

TO THIS DATA I DO THEE WED

dashboard course

Learn to build dynamic dashboards in Excel with Google Analytics data. 16 hours of video, 3 sample dashboards, 142-page workbook, practice Excel file, and more! Learn more.

FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER

SUBSCRIBE TO MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL

Privacy Policy
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2023 annielytics.com